NY-17 House Race 2026: Cait Conley vs Mike Lawler Odds
New York’s 17th District
NY-17 is held by Republican Mike Lawler, who is on the November 3 ballot against Democrat Cait Conley. One of the closer House seats on the board; the live contract below prices whether it flips.
Quick Answer
As of November 20, 2026, no side of the NY-17 House market is priced on the latest refresh — Kalshi's board is quiet, which is itself a signal about how much real money is engaged.
Seat currently held by Mike Lawler (R).
Why trust the price: prediction markets called all seven 2024 presidential swing states correctly, often while polling averages were still split. Our state-by-state audit grades where they missed too.
Prices updated Nov 20, 10:37 PM UTC · refreshed hourly through Election Day.
Who is running in NY-17

Cait Conley
Democrat—

Mike Lawler
Republican—
Live NY-17 House Market
Kalshi · CFTC-regulated · real moneyThe NY-17 House market is quiet right now — no priced contracts came back on the last refresh. District markets are thinner than statewide races; the 2026 Senate map & odds carries every live race.
NY-17 by the numbers
- Seat status
- Incumbent defense — Mike Lawler is a nominee.
- New York’s House map
- New York sends 26 members to the House, and no other district in the state trades on our board. New York’s map is failed: Dem redraw blocked for 2026; SCOTUS let existing lines stand (net effect 0).
NY-17 House 2026 — frequently asked
Who is favored to win the NY-17 House race in 2026?
The live board above shows the current market favorite — read each contract’s price as the market’s implied probability, so a 55¢ contract is a 55% chance. Going into the cycle the seat (New York’s 17th District) is held by Mike Lawler (Republican); because a real-money market reprices continuously, take today’s favorite off the price, not a static rating.
Who is running in NY-17 in 2026?
The general-election candidates for the NY-17 House race are Cait Conley (Democrat) and Mike Lawler (Republican), per the Kalshi contracts, whose rules name each candidate’s party as of 2026-10-06. Election Day is November 3, 2026.
How do I trade the NY-17 House market on Kalshi?
Kalshi lists the NY-17 House winner as YES/NO contracts, one per party, each settling at $1 if that side wins and $0 if it doesn’t. Buy the side you think is underpriced relative to your own probability, and the difference is your edge. Kalshi is CFTC-regulated and available in most states, with sports contracts restricted in some; every price on this page links straight to the live market.
How accurate were prediction markets in 2024?
Prediction markets had a strong 2024 — Kalshi and Polymarket called all seven presidential swing states correctly the night before, often while the polling averages were still split. Our full state-by-state scorecard, including where the markets missed, is in the 2024 accuracy audit linked below, and it’s the best base rate for how much to trust the NY-17 contract this cycle.
Get the Prediction Markets Picks Newsletter — midterm market alpha, free
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.