"Kalshi analysis" covers very different products, from a trading screen to a trade tape to a model that prices the market. The question that separates them is simple: does the tool tell you what it thinks a contract is worth, and does it publish how those calls turned out? Every competitor cell below was read from that company's own site on Nov. 15, 2026, and a dash means its own pages didn't say.
| What it shows | Its own model vs the market price | Public graded record of its own calls | Price | Venues | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PredictionMarketsPicks | Model-vs-market calls, plus free calculators (EV, Kelly, combos, Fed odds) | Yes | Yes, every engine, at /track-record | Free tools; Pro is $150/yr ($111 the first year) | Kalshi, Polymarket US, Polymarket.com and more |
| Kalshi Pro | Kalshi's own desktop trading workstation: order books, charts, a screener of about 2,000 markets | No | — | Free (beta) | Kalshi |
| KalshiScan | Live odds, public trader profiles and grades, leaderboards, a whale and live-trade tape | No (its methodology page says prices are the market's forecast, not its own) | — (it grades public traders, not its own calls) | Free | Kalshi; sister site for Polymarket |
| Alphascope | AI probability forecasts beside the market price, news context, Kalshi-to-Polymarket comparisons | Yes (AI probabilities) | — | Free to start; paid prices not shown | Polymarket, Kalshi, Manifold, Opinion |
| Kalshi Analytics | Kalshi market trends, probabilities and price history | No | — | — | Kalshi |
| MarketMaster | Kalshi and Polymarket data through an API, SDK and MCP server: EV edges, arbitrage, whale trades | — (it lists "EV edges" without saying whose probability they use) | — | Free tier; paid prices not shown | Kalshi, Polymarket |
Sources, all read Nov. 15, 2026: Kalshi's Kalshi Pro announcement · KalshiScan's homepage and methodology · Alphascope's homepage and predictions page · the Kalshi Analytics homepage · MarketMaster's own official MCP Registry entry (its website sat behind a login). Kalshinomics is left out: its homepage says it is winding down its public tools.
The column that matters: a graded record
Most tools on this list show you the market. A few show you a second opinion. Only one publishes the receipts. A model that disagrees with the market is worth something only if you can see how its disagreements have settled, and that includes the engines that lose. Here is ours, read live from the same ledger as /track-record:
Our edge engines have settled 3,192 timestamped signals against live Kalshi market resolutions — 1,735 winners, 1,457 losers, a combined 54% win rate, and +$139.72 net buying one contract per signal (+4.4¢ average per contract). Data as of 2026-11-15, read live from the same source as /track-record.
| Engine | Settled | Win rate | Net P/L | Avg / contract | Avg Brier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bitcoin Edge | 1,051 | 60% | +$60.65 | +5.8¢ | 0.1570 |
| Oil Edge | 663 | 47% | +$11.04 | +1.7¢ | 0.1846 |
| Gold Edge | 515 | 60% | +$34.34 | +6.7¢ | 0.1579 |
| Silver Edge | 423 | 57% | +$40.20 | +9.5¢ | 0.1455 |
| NHL Goal of the Day | 283 | 54% | +$2.46 | +0.9¢ | 0.1829 |
| Weather Edge | 257 | 35% | −$8.97 | −3.5¢ | 0.2284 |
Every signal is recorded before settlement and graded automatically against the market resolution. Net P/L is the sum across every settled signal, buying a flat 1 contract each time; Avg / contract is that sum divided by the signal count. Win rate excludes pushes. Brier score measures calibration — lower is better, 0.25 is coin-flip guessing. Negative engines stay published; that's the point. Plays of the Day are hand-picked rather than algorithmic, so they are graded separately on /track-record and are not in this table.
That is the difference we'd point to. Alphascope shows an AI probability next to the price, which is useful, but it didn't publish accuracy figures or a settled record on the pages we read. KalshiScan is the best trade tape of the group and says plainly that it makes no predictions.
Where each tool fits
- Placing the order: Kalshi Pro is Kalshi's own screen, free in beta, on the same account as the app.
- Watching who's trading: KalshiScan's tape, whale feed and trader grades.
- A second probability: Alphascope's AI forecasts, across four venues.
- A priced call you can audit: PredictionMarketsPicks, on Kalshi analysis, with every engine graded at /track-record.
- Inside an AI assistant: our tools also run as an MCP server next to Kalshi's official one; see MCP servers compared.
What PredictionMarketsPicks doesn't do
We don't place orders. A trade link opens the exchange, and you place any order yourself. We don't show a live order book the way Kalshi Pro does, and we don't track individual traders the way KalshiScan does. If one of our engines is losing, the scoreboard above says so. The free calculators are all on /tools.
