
Fun fact: a documentary has never been nominated for Best Picture at the Academy Awards.
I think that’s about to change.
Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s three-hour documentary, You Can See Everything — which has been screened twice for audiences and “blew the roof off the Telluride Film Festival” when it made its debut — has been getting rave reviews from critics who gingerly dance around the plot while heaping mostly unopposed praise on it. Its Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer score sits at 100. Its metacritic score is a 99. And yes, it’s still early, but a 99 on metacritic is reserved for classics. Here’s the list of every film (in chronological order) scoring exactly a 99 on metacritic (Note: there are a handful of 100s, and they’re what you would expect):
Intolerance (1916)
City Lights (1931)
The Rules of the Game (1939)
Pinocchio (1940)
Singin' in the Rain (1952)
Touch of Evil (1958)
Playtime (1967)
Army of Shadows (1969)
Shoah (1985)
Moonlight (2016)
Ryuichi Sakamoto | Opus (2023)
It was a review from The Guardian that made me run to Kalshi over the weekend, with lines like this throughout:
You Can See Everything is, somehow, more shocking, twistier, thornier and revealing than billed – a stupefying and gloriously destabilizing hall of psychological mirrors, a thrilling once-in-a-lifetime collision of director and subject
To my surprise, the movie was only trading at 3¢ to win the award for Best Picture. It has since risen to 6¢:

You Can See Everything has inspired a wave of “Why would I deceive you?” memes, which I think may have obfuscated the film’s pending masterpiece-ness. There’s been almost-unprecedented buzz after the two film festivals, and almost every review we’re going to see from here on out will likely look somewhat like The Guardian’s — acknowledging the hype… and then saying that the film somehow outperforms even the loftiest expectations.
So now it goes up against history. Can it be the first documentary to not only be nominated for “Best Picture,” but to also win? Is it good enough to beat The Odyssey, which was widely praised but took some dings for its storytelling? The current second favorite is The Black Ball, a multiple-timelines Spanish film that is, according to Variety’s review, “part literary mystery and part queer elegy, lyrical in patches and turgid in others”:

Dune: Part Three is in the market, as are Wild Horse Nine and The Social Reckoning. All of them are going to have detractors, flaws, and the inevitable “but” — “this is great, but…”
You Can See Everything, meanwhile, has gotten straight-up love from everyone.
I’m also going to add my tried-and-true logic to this one — the markets aren’t win or lose. You can sell your positions almost whenever you’d like. And so part of my thinking for the 3¢ buy — and even my double-down as a 6¢ buy — is knowing the media cycle and how the buzz will build over the next few days, weeks, and months. The movie has been screened publicly twice. There are twists that have been hinted at. The movie has been getting insane reviews despite the inability to spoil any of it. And we’re talking big, respectable outlets like Rolling Stone, New York Magazine, and even the sometimes-irascible Den of Geek — all giving the film nearly flawless reviews.
It’s a small sample, but a sign of things to come. As more critics see it and more reviews come out, there will be stories about how a documentary has never won Best Picture. Writers will start to make the case. Social media will carry it forward. The box office will set records — and then THAT will be a story. This movie will likely crush these numbers:

And the buzz will keep rolling along for this film we all know nothing about — except that it’s won over all the critics so far.
Additionally, there has always been a train of thought that late-season films are released as “Oscar bait.” They have momentum with voters, who start submitting ballots in December. This piece from Flasz on Film makes some great points, too, about the changing group of Oscar voters, and their tendencies to reward films that aren’t so obviously “Oscar bait”-ey as they were in the past:
Because the balance of voters has shifted… the prestige picture has evolved to focus on increased social consciousness, the plight of marginalized groups, inclusivity, and widely understood reckoning with America’s troubled past. Consequently, we have seen such “movies of the moment” like Parasite, Moonlight and even this year’s One Battle After Another take the top prize. These are films the Academy voters are likely to respond to…. I’d go as far as to suggest that in the coming years we will see a deluge of Sinners-like genre-adjacent prestige fare specifically targeting the Oscar race. The Oscar arithmetic has now been altered.
So, basically, the real “Oscar” buzz hasn’t even started yet. Once it does — and it’ll likely be around the film’s October 16th release date with a deluge of great reviews and accompanying think pieces on what it means for awards season — expect You Can See Everything to explode into contention in the markets… and then you can decide what you want to do with your shares.
If you don’t want to go all the way up to Best Picture winner, there’s still room to jump in on this film — again, to me, this is really surprising — in nomination and documentary categories.
The Tomatometer Score (current market)
I’m not touching this one, because the Tomatometer — for good or bad — allows a lot more reviewers into its aggregate than it should, and there will always be some people trying to make a name for themselves by authoring a bad review just to get some attention. I will offer this bit of “fine print” caution, though: the positions are labeled as “above” the number. So if you buy “above 96,” (currently 68¢), you need a 97-100 to win.
Best Documentary Film Feature (current market)
As of this newsletter, it’s sitting at 56%. I also own shares here. Maybe I’m missing something — am I overestimating the early reviews? Giving the voters too much credit? Even if you dismiss Fielder as a “TV guy,” you have Oppenheimer as the co-director, and he is a film festival superstar with legitimate documentary bona fides. Most of the concerns one can anticipate are covered. So why this isn’t at 70+ percent is perplexing to me. Maybe we’re just early?

Best Documentary Nominee (current market) and Best Picture Nominee (current market)
We’re currently at 76¢ and 42¢, respectively. I like these as smart places to jump in, but I’m a “take a big swing” guy, so “winning” on something that has a 76% chance of happening lacks the thrill. If you want to double your investment, though, getting in on Best Picture Nominee is a relatively easy way to do it. Again, you’re taking the risk that something weird happens between the October 16 release and the January 21 announcement of nominees — and not knowing any real details about the film adds a level of risk to it all. But, as always, we just want public opinion to push it up high enough to a point where we can at last have the option to cash out.
Am I missing something? Feel free to let me know (I think you can just reply to this email; if not: @nandodifino on X).
If I’m just early, though — and I think I am, as I’ve doubled my money in three days as the release date nears — this could be a great example of just thinking ahead on tentpole events that haven’t entered the public’s consciousness yet.