
If you were with us early on in this company’s still-young existence, you’ll remember our obsession with the “Survivor” markets. Dane Martinez and I did a weekly podcast on “Survivor,” we wrote newsletters, we all privately group chatted over the oddly-behaving markets. And we kind of knew, all along, that someone had to know something for Aubry Bracco to have held a 90%-ish chance of winning from the outset (outside of an early-April dip to 71% when a couple weekly “who will be eliminated?” markets were initially wrong).
The season played out with Aubry winning. We took a look at the season retrospectively and summed it all up thusly:
In a $32 million market, a player who was 80-90%-plus for most of the season won. And of course someone knew. Votes were cast and put into an urn last year. Producers, editors, network executives, contestants – the show passed through so many hands and edit bays OF COURSE people knew and OF COURSE they put money on the winner they had known ahead of time.
Kalshi and Polymarket got hammered the next morning. “Survivor” host Jeff Probst took a giant swing at both of them, although he was realistic about human nature, as is his job, in many ways:
“If the idea is that ‘Survivor’ needs to do a better job of managing our spoilers, you just don’t know anything about humans,” he told Variety after the season 50 finale. “That’s ridiculous. You’re telling me there’s a way I can make money by sharing information I have, and I might not ever get caught? Of course, people are going to do that. And if I found out somebody on our show bet on this, they’d be fired.”
Dustin Gouker of Event Horizon fame, chimed in after Probst’s comments with this headline in his newsletter:

…and it looks like the platforms listened!
Last season’s “Who Will Win Survivor?” market launched on January 11, a month and a half before the show’s February 25 debut:

Aubry, is, of course, the green line. As of this newsletter, there is no “Survivor” market on Kalshi or Polymarket. Rotowire has a tool! DraftKings has a blog post! Facebook has an AI summary! — but it looks like a $33 million market is juzst not going to materialize.
And it’s probably better that way, as we have learned from Dane’s excellent “Big Brother” coverage that if producers don’t know the outcome to a show ahead of time, the market behaves normally — and we can make great calls on them, as Dane had shares of Taylor at 5¢ in early August:

…and she’s now up to 16¢ and in the Final Four.

This is what a reality show market with no prior knowledge should look like:

We’re also finding the same kind of fun with “Dancing With the Stars,” as Gene Clemons — football coach, scout, Xs and Os genius — revealed himself to be a Theater minor in college who is an unabashed fan of the show. We’ve gone live the last two weeks touting the upside of Tatyana Ali, who is still, inexplicably, just 1¢:

And, once again, the show — with no insider knowledge sullying the market — has a normal-looking graph with some minor ebbs and flows as the season gets started:

And if you don’t feel like watching the video, Gene is also big on Julia Stiles, who is currently sitting at 3¢, and I have added shares of Amber Glenn, who is currently at 10¢. Olympians and athletes do well on this show, people!!
But back to where we started: there is no market for Survivor at the moment. Anywhere. And this is probably a good thing, as there is no real way to do anything without information leaking:
Words Jeff Probst may say? Plenty of people were there for it live and saw edits.
Weekly eliminations? Despite the markets being wrong for two separate weeks (and whether that was on purpose or not to drive down the actual choice, we will never know), they corrected around noon of that day and were on the right person well ahead of the episode airing.
Commercials aired during the episode? Planners and programmers know.
There would have to be, instead, some mini-segments of live challenges between former contestants to really create something that a market could run. Interstitial game shows, live beach-themed challenges on Paramount+… stuff like that. There IS a $30 million market out there looking for somewhere to put their money (and maybe you could say $15 million of that was non-insidery?), so perhaps producers and markets can get together before it’s too late and decide to do some live stunts with former castaways. Most of them host watch parties. They’re all looking for something to do!
For now, might I suggest just following Gene (aka the great Orunmila)’s advice and trying a DWTS market? For all the detractors of the failed Survivor experiment, there is an extremely fun layer added to watching a reality competition when you have $10 on a 1¢ underdog scoring an 18 and being the first celebrity declared safe in Week 2.