
Sorry Fighting Irish fans but let's bust this bubble before it gets too big: CJ Carr is not winning the Heisman Trophy. Tim Brown's 39-year-old streak is safe. And it’s crazy to think that 1987 was the last time a Notre Dame player won the prestigious individual award. But guess what? It will not change this year. Here’s a look at Notre Dame’s Heisman performance in beautiful bar graph form (done on the Comet browser, my new favorite toy):

All pretty graphs aside, Carr is trading at 9% on Polymarket (behind Mensah and Manning)and 12% on Kalshi (where he is the favorite). The Heisman Trophy market is trading over 11 million dollars and growing by the minute on Kalshi alone:

So why is Carr not winning the Heisman? Well, the award seems to come down to criteria that will not be in the quarterback's favor, no matter how good he is.
Can Carr put up Fernando Mendoza numbers? Of course he can — but will it be against Big Ten or SEC competition? Absolutely not. Their bastardized ACC schedule, mixed with lower-level Big Ten competition and sprinkled with a couple G5 schools, is not going to convince anyone that the Irish's path to success was an arduous one. Too many games against inferior opponents will cause voters to not look at impressive numbers the same was as players competing against the upper echelon. Quarterbacks like Dante Moore (trading at 9%) have to go through the Big Ten; Arch Manning (trading at 9%) will have to navigate the SEC. They will get more love because of it.
The other, more mystical, thing working against Carr is that he is the favorite to win the award. How? I have no real legitimate idea other than he's the quarterback at Notre Dame. The reality is that over the past 20 years, only one preseason favorite to win the Heisman Trophy has claimed the award — that was Marcus Mariota in 2014. Last season everyone was on the Arch Manning hype train and that was derailed rather quickly over the first couple weeks. Mendoza was not in any conversations about the Heisman at that time, and we know how it ended.
Far more accomplished collegiate signal callers went into their Heisman campaigns as the frontrunner and walked away empty handed.
Tim Tebow won it as a sophomore in 2007 (over Arkansas RB Darren McFadden) and was the favorite the next two seasons ,where he put up all time great numbers en route to one of the most remarkable careers in college football. He lost out to Oklahoma quarterback Sam Bradford in 2008 and Alabama running back Mark Ingram in 2009.
In 2010 Ohio State quarterback Terrelle Pryor, a physical freak at the position with the rarest combination of size, speed, arm talent, and charisma, was the preseason favorite. The eventual winner was a “super serum” version of Pryor — Auburn wunderkind Cam Newton. The eventual first overall pick was arguably the greatest one-man show in college football history.
Johnny Heisman was primed for a repeat before Famous Jameis exploded on the scene in 2013. Bryce Young was the favorite to repeat in 2022, but Caleb Williams won. In 2023 it was Williams’ turn to make a Heisman run as a favorite and previous season's winner; Jayden Daniels took it home.
So let’s get to it. Here are a few guys trading at low percentages who could be in New York striking that famous pose by season's end. And remember, in the markets, momentum and buzz are going to mean something, as that 3¢ LaNorris Sellers could turn into a 65¢ asset by Halloween, and you can sell whenever you want.
Sam Leavitt, QB, LSU (4%)
The obvious Arizona State-to-LSU pipeline that saw Jayden Daniels win a Heisman is an easy comp. But Leavitt will be playing in a much better offense with the opportunity to throw the ball all over the place to elite-level receivers, at tight end, at running back, and on the perimeter. With so many mouths to feed, they will be pressing the gas even in blowouts to try to keep all of the talent happy. That means more statistics for Leavitt.
LaNorris Sellers, QB, South Carolina (3%)
Sellers is a bully at quarterback, a guy who can be physically dominant running the ball and who continues to emerge as a passer. If the work he's done in the off-season allows him to take the next step with his arm, this could be a guy putting up impressive video game-like numbers at South Carolina.
Bryce Underwood, QB, Michigan (2%)
Things are not as bad as they made it seem at Michigan in order to run their former coach out of town, but it definitely got better with a rock-solid, quality head coach in former Utah head guy Kyle Whittingham. Underwood is big, fast, athletic, and will have weapons to throw to in an offense that should be much improved in 2026.
Malachi Toney, WR, Miami (2%)
Malachi Toney might be the most electric football player in all of college. He has a high-profile program to support his campaign, and a quarterback in Darien Mensah to get him the football. He could have a Percy Harvin-level impact on winning for Miami in 2026.
So before it even begins, it's over. Don't test drive Carr, there's no lemon law in college football.
You DO want to hang out with The 7 Oracles. Go to the site and check out everything to help you invest wisely this season on college football, politics, Rotten Tomato scores, Bitcoin, and of course the NFL. Or just come and enjoy the data and keep your wallet in your virtual pocket. Either way, use promo NFLEDGE to get 50% off your first subscription (even if it's a full year subscription 👀).