If you read to the bottom of Wednesday’s newsletter, you’ll recall an inner struggle I had in not wanting to actively participate in an outcome of a market. Specifically, the Rotten Tomatoes score for The Odyssey. It currently stands at 96; I have a position on it being above 97. That cost has shrunk from 11 cents yesterday to a sad 2 cents today:

If you go to the page with all the reviews for The Odyssey, you’ll see, in small print on the left side, a link that reads: Do you think we mischaracterized a critic's review?
Today, I do.

Click on it and you’re led to a page where it asks you to explain yourself.

I have read and re-read Nick Newman’s review of the movie on Film Stage. The more you read it, the more tangled it becomes. I asked Comet — the Perplexity-run browser — if it was a positive or negative… it said negative. I pressed Comet for a review out of five stars and it said 2.5. But I think it’s cheating; Comet keeps citing other outlets who have pointed Newman’s review out as one of the few negative ones. Like, for instance, the Daily Beast:

And we have created a self-prophesizing circle here, as The Daily Beast saw a rotten rating, rolled with it, and Comet is pulling that info instead of critically reading the actual review. So I’ll do this myself!
Yes, Newman — Managing Editor of Film Stage — refers to the film as “enervating” in a headline he likely wrote himself. But he also praises the movie several times throughout the review. This isn’t the language someone uses in a 2.5-star review:
“His final product often entertains”
“there’s an impressive, sometimes remarkable coherence in his quick flits between multiple timelines”
“An episodic, peripatetic structure permits some delightful surprises”
“In stretches when the epic begins to play as thoroughgoing, body-transformation effects equal to Cronenberg or An American Werewolf in London leave fine fingerprints” (I think this is positive)
“Still, an indebtedness to the natural world pervades”
“Maybe it is just nice to have any reprieve, be that on IMAX 70mm or DCP, from the world into which The Odyssey arrives”
Newman makes a point in the middle about the overuse of awe-inspiring moments essentially making none of them truly awe-inspiring. And that’s the part Rotten Tomatoes decided to highlight.

So I submitted a “miscategorized” flag to the site.
And then I reached out to Nick Newman.
And he didn’t reply.
Just to be extremely clear, I sent Nick an email and told him I just wanted to talk about his review and get some quotes for this follow-up, not that I thought he should also write to Rotten Tomatoes and petition for a “fresh” rating so we could gloriously get the Tomatometer up to 98, hand in hand. I even bolded a sentence in the email that listed my prior editing and writing stops (WSJ, The Athletic, CBS, ESPN) so he didn’t think I was the film critic equivalent of Ben Patz.
Patz, if you’ve never heard of him, was sentenced to 36 months of probation for sending violent and threatening tweets to athletes who caused his bets to lose.
You know… this guy!

As of now, we only have hair dryers and teleprompter operators. Soon, though, I wouldn’t be surprised if we stumble upon the prediction markets equivalent of Parlay Patz:
Hours have passed. Nick Newman is ignoring me. Should I tweet at him and tell him he sucks? Threaten to drive to New York and punch him in the face? Maybe I should message In Between Drafts’ Jon Winkler on LinkedIn and tell him to put $1000 on “above 97” and then write a new “fresh” review saying he changed his mind and we all win that way? Maybe convince some of his friends who gave rotten reviews to do the same? Maybe word it so he doesn’t have a choice and he’ll be sorry if he doesn’t?
I will take the L and learn from this. Maybe. Possibly. I probably should see the movie first, but when you swing the doors open to 240 critics, some of them are going to pick apart what I assume is high art (NOTE: I once impulsively bought DVDs of The Prestige for my friends at a bar on amazon because they hadn’t seen it — and I also subscribe to this incredible theory about the movie and Tesla if anyone cares to click away at it) just to pick something beautiful apart.
In other words:

As for me? I’m on to July 24th releases, including…
