
There is a person in my life who insists that Ben Shelton is a dweeb. That person — who may or may not be editing this article — needs to be told, in no uncertain terms:
No, he isn’t.
The last time I wrote a newsletter, it was about how all of my New York sports friends were having fun and I wasn’t. Today, I’m here to tell you that I am having fun. Ben Shelton pulled off a number of miracles Tuesday night — or, technically, Wednesday morning — not the least of which was keeping me entertained past 3:30 a.m. on a Tuesday night…without waking up filled with shame.
There were other — more traditionally athletic — notables, too:
The match began at 11:05 p.m. Tuesday and ended at 3:33 a.m. Wednesday — the latest finish in US Open history. It lasted four hours and 28 minutes.
Shelton ended it with a 146 mph ace at 3:33 in the morning.
Alcaraz entered the match 15–1 in five-set matches and had won his previous 12 straight. Shelton made him 15–2.
Alcaraz had never lost to an American or a left-handed player at a Grand Slam before Shelton. Shelton broke both streaks in the same night.
Shelton had been 0–17 against top-three players, winning only one set across those matches. His first victory came against the defending US Open champion.
Alcaraz arrived on an 18-match Grand Slam winning streak. Shelton ended that too.
The semifinal between Shelton and Frances Tiafoe guarantees an American man in the final. It also guarantees the first Black American man in a Grand Slam final since Arthur Ashe — yes, the man they named the stadium after — in 1972.
However, the most useful fact for the real argument is that, after the match, Carlos Alcaraz himself called Shelton “a beast.” Which is, checks notes, not a dweeby quality at all.
Anyone who follows me knows by now that I am not really about the stats so much as I am about the vibes — the tea leaves, if you will. So let me tap into that a bit. Because of everything listed above, Shelton has the sports world raving about tennis on opening night of the NFL season.
David slung a stone to slay Goliath. Shelton took his out with nothing but a tennis racket, a ball, and a 146 mph serve.
In July, we did a show outlining why we all believed it was time for Shelton to show the world that he is the next great American tennis star (one of us splurged on his rookie card off eBay). Although he had a disappointing showing on grass, last night confirmed that we were more early than wrong.
He also created a cute little viral moment with Trinity. That was nice.
Yesterday was a great day to be a tennis fan, an American sports fan, and a Ben Shelton Guy.
For the bona fides: I watched Shelton make his Grand Slam debut in 2022. He arrived with some buzz after winning the NCAA singles championship. He had a spark, but it is always impossible to know what that will become. Throughout the years, I have watched him beat himself and wondered what it might look like if he were really, really focused and on his game — if he limited the mistakes and just kicked ass.
It was worth the wait.
Now, let’s talk business.
I don’t think Tiafoe and Shelton will have a particularly close match. They’re both coming off instant classics, but the momentum has to favor Ben…right? At least I think so. The market thinks so:

I look at it like this — Shelton did something last night that I am fairly convinced Tiafoe cannot. Tiafoe dug deep and won an awesome quarterfinal against Alex Michelsen, who had not dropped a single set all tournament. That is nothing to shake a stick at, but I can’t help thinking that Shelton wouldn’t have found himself in the position Frances had to escape.
Prediction: Ben in four. He may drop the first or second set. I also think he goes on to win the entire thing. However, as of this writing, the quarterfinals haven’t yet concluded, so let’s see how those go before we get excited.
Here’s that graph, either way:

Other Tea Leaves
Ladies
I (sadly) think Sabalenka is going to walk through Pegula. She just looks too strong. I also think the Bills are going to the Super Bowl — and this is a Thanos/Gamora-style sacrifice for that to happen. My heart says Coco (who just won in another great match) will get revenge for her fellow American in the final. I’m going to listen to it.

Honey Deuce
Last night on Kalshi, I bought YES that Honey Deuce sales will pass 950,000 units. I was there last Monday, had four of them and was only there until 11:30. Multiple evening matches have gone well past midnight, and the crowd is absolutely electric every time. Tuesday alone featured something like 17 hours of tennis.

Not Tennis
Rashid Shaheed is scoring a touchdown and gaining more than 60 yards tonight on Netflix. He was given a larger-than-expected contract after having some success toward the end of last season and showing a few flashes in the playoffs. With a full offseason—and a coach and GM who seemingly make no poor decisions committing him to that contract—I think they plan to use him. I think they plan to show us that early.
In short, Ben Shelton is not a dweeb.