
Our “Tomatometer” history here has not been the best. BUTTTTT it’s getting better. We went from a terrible take on “The Mandalorian and Grogu” to being one review shy of a win on “The Odyssey.” In between we correctly called the Scream 7 spiral. YAY(?)
Today’s take is a more muted one — can Disney’s latest movie, “Hexed,” get a 70+ — or even a 75+ — on the Tomatometer?
I say yes. A forceful yes, in fact! And if you feel sheepish about that, you can drop down to Above 70 and even Above 65 and still get great value.

As you can see, the “forecast” is 60.6%. The higher-end market looks like this (and keep in mind, these are worded as “above,” so if you go “Above 60,” you need a 61 or more. A 60 won’t do it):
Above 60: 51%
Above 65: 42%
Above 70: 36%
Above 75: 27%
Above 80: 19%
The buzz for “Hexed” hasn’t been overwhelmingly good. In fact, it’s been a little non-existent. But don’t conflate box office with Tomatometer. On Google Trends, “Hexed,” which comes out a week from today, on November 25, has been up — and then back down — over the last month:

Here’s the Trend line for “Wish,” which was released Nov. 22, 2023. That big spike at the end starts on Nov. 19, three days before release. So if tradition holds, we’ll see that around Nov. 22 this year:

The movie was made by the same people who had their hands in “Zootopia,” “Zootopia 2,” “Encanto,” and, yes, “Wish.” Fawn Veerasunthorn was the head of story for “Raya and the Last Dragon.” As you can see below, that’s a mish-mash of big hits and weird misses:
Movie | Release Year | Tomatometer Score | Rotten Tomatoes Status |
Zootopia 2 | 2025 | 92% | Certified Fresh |
Moana 2 | 2024 | 61% | Fresh |
Wish | 2023 | 48% | Rotten |
Strange World | 2022 | 72% | Fresh |
Encanto | 2021 | 92% | Certified Fresh |
Raya and the Last Dragon | 2021 | 93% | Certified Fresh |
Frozen II | 2019 | 77% | Certified Fresh |
Ralph Breaks the Internet | 2018 | 88% | Certified Fresh |
Moana | 2016 | 95% | Certified Fresh |
Zootopia | 2016 | 98% | Certified Fresh |
Quick note on what looks like an error: “Frozen 2” was certified fresh and then more negative reviews came in after. So today we all learned that “Certified Fresh” is a designation that can never be taken away from you.
Ever.
Just kidding, if it goes below 70 they take it away. So it’s safe… but still misleading.
Anyway, a quick scan of this list otherwise, and I have a couple thoughts. “Raya and the Last Dragon” was a sorely underrated movie; it had a limited theater release during COVID and I think the initial “you must pay to see this on Disney+” thing turned a lot of people off to it. But I liked it! It was different and fun. And sad. And happy. Typical Disney far. “Moana 2” was supposed to be a TV series, so that 61 was probably a result of that all being crammed into a movie, so I don’t want to put too much weight on that. “Wish” was a groan-inducer BUT the re-watchability factor on it is sky-high. I know! I didn’t think it was, either, but try it. There are still incredibly cringey parts but the songs are great and the story is mostly harmless.
Yes, I am trying to create a defense of “Wish,” because this “comes from the people who brought you” that movie.
And we can go over the recent track record all we like, but “Hexed” has another factor weighing down the projected score that we should be able to take advantage of: 4chan users posted a bunch of things about the film having multiple screenings with bad testing scores and several changes being made to it as production went along. There were even rumors — that were quickly dismissed — that the film was centered (literally centered on the screen) in a way to make it friendlier for posting on vertical social media like TikTok. This is where I think people are doing different things with the same information.
I am dismissing most of it. People hate Disney, people love Disney. It’s easy to post something and let it spread just to watch the world burn.
But let’s just play along and say it’s true. If changes were made, we have to assume they were made early in the process. The original story had a boy as the main character when it was announced in 2025 but a year later it was a girl; this seems to be an issue for the internet but if it made the movie better — great? Plus this isn’t a live-action film where you can do relatively easy reshoots. Animated films are intense. The “Win or Lose” miniseries took six years to make! So if they changed it, they did it early and for good reason; it was not a task lightly undertaken.
The trailer also looks fun and the only song released to date — a cover of the Cars’ “Magic” by Hailee Steinfeld — sounds great. People want to compare this movie to “Wish” bombing… but “Wish” was an odd little duck — it was a heavily Easter-egg’d “tribute” to 100 years of Disney. They tried to jam too much in — way too many references — and people left unfulfilled because it felt like things were added into the plot just for the sake of a “nudge nudge” at the audience. This is a new era of movie-watchers. You can’t (SPOILER ALERT) provide origin stories for the Magic Mirror and the Fairy Godmother, then make other different references to Peter Pan (just for one example), and not have viewers and fans then go back and check every inch of the film for consistency and plot holes. It was a disaster on Rotten Tomatoes. And despite it having that high rewatchability factor, it doesn’t make a difference in initial reviews.
You have to have a little faith here, that Disney learned from its mistakes with “Wish” and maybe returned to a solid, fun, uncomplicated musical film that people will love. I am a fan of the trailer. It could be leaving things out that test audiences didn’t like, but it feels fun, and I’m banking on it being a surprise hit.
Longshot market + Defiantly Ignoring Anonymous Internet Rumors? I’m in.
I bought shares of “Above 75.” And I really think I may go back and get a few “above 85” — because this could either bomb or be a giant beloved 90+ Tomatometer hit that demands a sequel.